We came down in the
morning to crumbs on a plate
and a type-written
letter praising us for being good.
It was signed in a
scrawl we only saw once a year,
spindly and tall with
curlicues on the “S” and “A”
that we knew were not
from our mother’s even hand.
Somehow we were
unconcerned that he had had been
watching us to be sure we behaved, were deserving.
There were footprints
on the hearth, the deep ruts
of men’s work boots
imprinted on a pile of spilled ash.
I believed much
longer than I should have, convinced
he wouldn’t go to so
much trouble to sign the gift tags,
to shake ash on the
hearth and step into it with careful
heavy feet, and hide
carrot tops in a bowl on the roof
to discover when
cleaning the gutters months later.
That streak of magic
that no one expected made us so
easy to fool. I drank up every bit of proof that it
was real.
Yet when I finally accepted
the he behind it all, there was
no disappointment,
just the low, blue flame of wonder
at the efforts of
that distant man, incapable of deceit,
who had been watching
us year after year, his three
good girls, finding a
way to tell us we were deserving.